the film blog that's officially banned by the Chinese government!
Showing posts with label Roman Polanski. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Roman Polanski. Show all posts

31 May 2010

SHUTTER ISLAND: nightmares in a damaged brain

Director Martin Scorsese's first foray into the horror genre is a major disappointment. SHUTTER ISLAND trots out every cliche in the "How to Make a Horror Thriller" handbook with not even a single smudged fingerprint to indicate this is the handiwork of the greatest living American film director.
If it weren't for the presence of the (still) unfeasibly babyfaced Leonardo DiCaprio I'd swear I was watching the 1966 cinematic bastard lovechild of William Castle and a young Roman Polanski. Imagine "Cul de Sac" meets "Strait Jacket." 
With a blaring discordant soundtrack and cast of demented murderous souls locked away on a remote island institution and guarded by a staff whose own sanity appears dubious, I half expected a late era Joan Crawford or Bette Davis to loom out of the darkness on the other end of one of the pairs of arms reaching through the bars to grab at the hero as he stumbles down a damp, dark corridor in a mental hospital.
SHUTTER ISLAND is derivative, hokey, overblown and peopled with stock characters. There's Ben Kingsley as the smooth head doctor whose professions of concern for his patients may or may not be sincere; Max von Sydow as the German-accented psychiatrist who may or may not be a Nazi war criminal; Ted Levine as the warden whose honesty and openness may be concealing a sadistic dark side, and DiCaprio as the outsider, menaced on all sides and starting to doubt his own sanity. 
In the hands of William Castle this would all add up to a taut, entertaining B-movie chiller but it's not worthy of a director of Scorsese's stature. His 2004 film "The Aviator" for which he was undeservedly Oscar nominated looks like "Raging Bull" compared to SHUTTER ISLAND.   

01 May 2010

THE GHOST WRITER: masterful suspense from a masterful director

It's been a while since a film gave me chills but I got them all over and more than once while watching THE GHOST WRITER. What caused them wasn't a creepy old house, or a hideously deformed psycho-killer looming out of the dark, or a sudden hand on the shoulder of the protagonist when we thought they were alone, or any of those other hoary old tricks employed to make us jump in our seat.
It was the sense of overwhelming fear which suddenly engulfed me when the unexpected discovery of a piece of information by the main character made both of us realise that his life was in immediate and serious danger. This is genuine suspense. It doesn't rely on a jarring blast of music or jump cut editing; it arises organically out of the unfolding story.
In the hands of veteran (and to some people - legendary) director Roman Polanski, the story which unfolds in THE GHOST WRITER is utterly absorbing and totally gripping. Ewan McGregor stars as a writer (known only as "The Ghost") who finds himself in way over his head when he agrees to take on the ghost writing of the memoirs of recently retired British Prime Minister Adam Lang (Pierce Brosnan). Within days of joining Lang at his borrowed, bunker-like estate on Martha's Vineyard off the coast of Massachusetts,  the former PM is accused of war crimes in connection with the rendition of 4 suspected Muslim terrorists, and the writer uncovers evidence which suggests that Lang has something in his past that he wants to keep hidden.
It may just be coincidence that a charismatic director living in exile from his adopted homeland and unable to travel freely for fear of arrest and extradition to the USA to face controversial sex crime charges has chosen to make a story about a charismatic politician who finds himself unable to return home for fear of arrest, but it's difficult to resist making comparisons between Lang and Polanski. Has Polanski's empathy with Lang's situation influenced his depiction of the man as a complicated character who can be perceived in many different ways by different people?
It's similarly difficult not to draw analogies with Tony Blair when watching Lang. The film never suggests that Lang is a stand-in for Blair, but both men are charismatic, relatively young former leaders who had an uncomfortably close (for some) relationship with the USA,  who led the United Kingdom into unpopular wars to support the American President, and who remain controversial figures even out of office.  
These convergences, whether unintentional or not, contribute to the credibility of THE GHOST WRITER as a piece of docudrama rather than just another fictional thriller. We think we know enough about the "secret" world of international political intrigue to believe that the events explored in this film are plausible, and the fact that the moments of suspense are not contrived or cliched merely adds to the sense that we're watching events that aren't too far removed from reality.
Pierce Brosnan is probably not the first actor you'd think of when casting for the British Prime Minister but he works. That, I would argue, is because we have Tony Blair as a role model. Brosnan would have been a ridiculous choice for the part if we'd only had John Major or Neil Kinnock to compare him to.
Ewan McGregor's never been one of my favourite actors but he's effective in a part which has the potential, if overplayed, to diminish the story's believability. The Ghost never resorts to superhero actions to drag himself out of dangerous situations. The only unconvincing aspect to The Ghost's character is his London accent which has a tendency to drift north towards Hadrian's Wall on occasion.
(Talking of accents, it may be significant or nothing more than coincidence that only one of the five leading actors speaks in their natural accent, but I'll say no more).
THE GHOST WRITER follows in the footsteps of two of Polanski's greatest movies - "Rosemary's Baby" and "Chinatown" - in peeling back the covers to partially reveal a hidden, parallel present where the lust for power, control and secrecy takes precedence over individual life. 
Similarly stylish, sophisticated and spotted with moments of black humour, this is a superior piece of adult entertainment which will keep you hooked until the final frame.